Travel Tuesdays: luggage

April 27th, 2010

Let’s face it: it’s called luggage because you lug it around. So if you’re planning to do any travel at all, you want something that’s easy to lug. But if you share my preference for traveling with a carry-on only, that ups the ante.

Of course, I acknowledge that sometimes checking your bag is unavoidable — say, if you’re traveling with tools, a case of wine, or a wedding dress. But if I can avoid it, I do. Why? Lots of reasons. If my luggage is with me at all times, it’s less likely to get lost or stolen or accidentally taken by someone else. I can be on my way while everyone else is waiting at baggage claim for their stuff to show up. I don’t have to pay the extortionate fees some airlines are charging to check in a bag. Besides, when I travel, I prefer to be inconspicuous — and as Rick Steves likes to remind people, nothing turns on the blinking neon light reading “Tourist here! Scammers welcome!” like wrestling with a big suitcase or two.

I consider certain qualities necessary in a carry-on bag:

  1. It has to be large enough to hold a week’s worth of clothing. I pack light and will happily do laundry, or at least rinse stuff out in the sink, if I’m on the go for more than a week — but I need to know I can go for a week on what I have with me.
  2. And yet it still has to weigh 15 pounds or less when fully packed, because dude, I am not a weightlifter.
  3. It has to fit in an overhead compartment. Seriously. I am not willing to be forced to check it at the door when it turns out at the last minute to be an inch over the maximum in every direction.
  4. I have to be able to carry it on my back. A rolling suitcase just isn’t as maneuverable or convenient as something I can wear, but a big bag is cumbersome and uncomfortable when carried by a shoulder strap for more than a few minutes.
  5. It needs to be sturdy. Rip-resistant fabric. Heavy-duty zippers. Solidly stitched seams. I do not want my clothes suddenly falling out in some filthy subway station (or, indeed, anywhere else).
  6. It needs some kind of organizational features. I like useful pockets. Otherwise, I inevitably end up having to unpack everything to find a pair of socks.
  7. Ideally, it should have an easy-to-access place to store the stuff we must now carry in a little plastic baggie and whip out for TSA. I don’t want to have to pack, unpack, and repack at every security checkpoint.

You really don’t have to drop a ton of cash on a bag, either. For the last seven years, I’ve been traveling with a big blackĀ backpack bought at my local cheap-luggage-from-China store for the princely sum of $25.

Amortized over the time I’ve owned it, that works out to about $3.57 a year — and there’s no question I’ve gotten my money’s worth. I’ve schlepped it to Paris, Dublin, Amsterdam, Venice, London (thrice), Rome (twice), and a bunch of domestic destinations including New York (at least half a dozen times), New Orleans, Milwaukee, St. Louis, Las Vegas, and Portland, Oregon.

However, on its last outing, I cracked the buckle on the waist strap — so I’m looking at the Tom Bihn Aeronaut. This is essentially my dream bag; it meets all my requirements and then some.

I have been lusting after this marvelous creation since I first laid eyes on it several years ago. It’s light, sturdy, and capacious. It has handles, a shoulder strap, and a backpack harness that zips away in its own cunningly designed compartment. It has water-resistant zippers. It’s designed not to spill your crap all over the place when you open it. It has dividers and pockets. You can even buy little packing cubes that fit inside for even more organization. In short, it is awesome.

Sadly, it is also $220.

But here’s the thing about budget travel: sometimes, you have to pay a little more to get a lot more. (More on that later.) Although the frugal side of me balks at the idea of dropping $220 on a bag, even the bag of my dreams, it works out to $22 a year if I get ten years of use out of it. Given the amount I (don’t) travel, I could probably use it for 15 or 20 years, especially since Bihn bags come with a lifetime guarantee. Heck, I’ve been carrying a Bihn Small Cafe Shoulder Bag almost every day for almost five years and it’s still going strong.

So I’m tempted. Perhaps I’ll have a new bag to test for my next trip. Or perhaps I’ll give the big black backpack one final fling before I retire it.

What’s your favorite bag? Why do you like it? Would you recommend it to me?

Join the Travel Hacking Cartel